Application Details

Council BCC
Reference 24/03316/F
Address 23 Dundridge Lane Bristol BS5 8SE  
Street View
Ward St George Troopers Hill
Proposal Erection of one new dwelling and associated parking.
Validated 2024-09-18
Type Full Planning
Status Pending consideration
Neighbour Consultation Expiry 2024-10-16
Standard Consultation Expiry 2024-10-24
Determination Deadline 2024-11-13
BCC Planning Portal on Planning Portal
Public Comments Supporters: 0 Objectors: 6  Unstated: 1  Total: 7
No. of Page Views 0
Comment analysis   Date of Submission
Links
Nearby Trees Within 200m

BTF response: OBJECT

Here are our comments of 03 October 2024

Public Comments

Not Available    on 2024-10-15   OBJECT

This is a fast road for children, this house will be out of character for the area, and verydangerous where it will be built. If this goes ahead. this will end in a fatal accident waiting tohappen.

Not Available    on 2024-10-15   OBJECT

This is a fast road for children, this house will be out of character for the area, and verydangerous where it will be built. If this goes ahead. this will end in a fatal accident waiting tohappen. number 23 has only 1 off street parking, and it is a 3 bedroom house.

Not Available    on 2024-10-09   OBJECT

This proposed property looks completly out of character for the area as far as I canmake out from the plans. I think the parking area is in a dangerous area pulling out on a narrowand steep hill,polly barnes hill. lots of children use polly barnes hill to and from school on bikes andscooters. the scrubland is important to lots of wildlife in the area foxes,badgers,squirrels,manysmall birds .hole in the boundery may have badgers. not a suitable place for this property to beerected.

    on 2024-10-04   OBJECT

    on 2024-10-03  

Comments – 03 October 2024

2

assigned as having high strategic significance.

Biodiversity gain

On this basis, the trees on site have a habitat value of 0.11 habitat units, not the 0.39 habitat units the applicant calculates. We do not take issue with the applicant’s other habitat calculations.

As the consequence, the net habitat loss is 24.29%, not 12.73%. This means there is a shortfall of 0.11 habitat units between the applicant’s proposals and the 10% net gain it aspires to.

The Watercourse habitats also show no net gain, a shortfall of 0.01 habitat units despite the statutory obligation to achieve at least a 10% net gain.

Our Headline results are set out below at Figure 1.

Figure 1: Headline Results.

Comments – 03 October 2024

3

There is also a difference between the baseline habitat area of 0.0452 hectares and the combined habitats retained and created – 0.0493 hectares. This needs to be resolved. This perhaps because the applicant’s Biodiversity Statement and Biodiversity Gain Plan3 reports that the site is 0.055 hectares, whereas 0.0452 hectares as recorded in the Statutory Metric calculation.4

The trading rules will also have to be complied with.

We note that the applicant has not submitted any proposals for how these losses will be mitigated or offset; it is not obliged to at this stage. However, we ask that the LPA exercise its discretion to require this5 so that it can be established whether what may be proposed is viable and meets the aspirations of the LPA for offsetting to be as local as possible to the loss. It will also give stakeholders an opportunity to comment on the proposals, which will not possible if the application is granted.

3 24_03316_F-BIODIVERSITY_STATEMENT___BIODIVERSITY_GAIN_PLAN-3758918 – para. 2.7. 4 24_03316_F-BIODIVERSITY_METRIC-3758919. 5 https://www.gov.uk/guidance/biodiversity-net-gain#biodiversity-net-gain-submitting-a-planning-application -

Paragraph: 013 Reference ID: 74-013-20240214.

    on 2024-09-29   OBJECT

Commenter Type: Other

Stance: Customer objects to the Planning Application

Comment Reasons:

Comment:THIS DEVELOPMENT WILL STILL HAVE A MASSIVE IMPACT ON THE LOCAL

CHARACTER OF THE STREET SCENE AS WAS THE CASE IN 2021 TOP OF POLLY BARNES

HILL DUNDRIDGE LANE REALLY BECOMING OVERCROWDED WITH HOUSES IN PEOPLES

BACK GARDENS

Not Available    on 2024-09-28   OBJECT

I object to the above planning application on safety grounds.Traffic goes very quickly in both directions on Polly Barnes Hill and I don't the entrance and exit isin a safe place.